SC: Child’s right to know father outweighs privacy | India News



NEW DELHI: Putting a child’s right to know about his biological father on a higher pedestal in comparison to a person’s right to privacy not to be compelled to undergo a DNA test, Supreme Court has directed a man to go through the test on a paternity suit filed by a youth who claims to be his biological son.A bench of Justices Sanjay Karol and N K Singh adjudicated a tricky issue–whose rights would prevail in paternity test battle –the right to privacy of a man not to undergo DNA test or the right of a child to know about his father? The court held that balance of interests lies in favour of the child and passed order in his favour. It rejected the plea of the man who resisted the test on the ground that he did not have a physical relationship with the child’s mother.The court noted that the mother of the youth had also fought a long legal battle against him for getting her due and maintenance for the son which ended in Supreme Court and matters became infructuous as the son became a major by the time the case reached the apex court. The man, however, told the court that he was given a clean chit in the rape case filed against him by her and it should put to rest all allegation. Refusing to examine the nature of the relationship between them which was not the issue before it, the court decided the case from the perspective of youth’s legitimate interest in knowing his biological father.The youth, who is now 26-years old, submitted that there is no other recourse available to determine the question of paternity in view of the continuous denial by his father. He filed suit for declaration of paternity and share in property.“Although there have been findings that state that the second respondent has been unable to establish any link between CP and Pankaj (name changed), those findings were not as a consequence of the full-dress trial. The civil suit filed by Pankaj is for this very purpose and as such, the question of paternity is directly in issue. On this count as well, we find in favour of the respondent(youth),” it said.The SC bench also said that the balance of interests definitely lies in favour of the youth and upheld the orders passed by trial court and Chhattisgarh high court in favour of DNA test.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Rahul Gandhi’s ‘advice’ to PM Modi, and 3 guarantees to students over police action on protesters | India News

    NEW DELHI: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Wednesday accused the Centre of denying him an opportunity to speak in the Lok Sabha because he held Union home minister Amit Shah…

    Evening News Wrap: Air India crash probe finds no fuel switch fault; RS clears Vande Mataram Bill & more | India News

    The government says no fault has been found in the Air India Boeing 787 fuel control switch, while the crash investigation continues.Parliament has cleared a Bill extending legal protection to…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    World Cup final referee Slavko Vinčić makes major career decision one week after Spain-Argentina final | Football News

    World Cup final referee Slavko Vinčić makes major career decision one week after Spain-Argentina final | Football News

    Rahul Gandhi’s remarks on student protests trigger Parliament showdown: What happened next | India News

    Rahul Gandhi’s remarks on student protests trigger Parliament showdown: What happened next | India News

    Rahul Gandhi’s ‘advice’ to PM Modi, and 3 guarantees to students over police action on protesters | India News

    Mcdavid: What does Connor McDavid do outside hockey? Inside the NHL star’s life away from the ice | NHL News

    Mcdavid: What does Connor McDavid do outside hockey? Inside the NHL star’s life away from the ice | NHL News

    Vaibhav Sooryavanshi’s meteoric rise! 15-year-old jumps 230 places in ICC T20I rankings as Ishan Kishan scripts history | Cricket News

    Vaibhav Sooryavanshi’s meteoric rise! 15-year-old jumps 230 places in ICC T20I rankings as Ishan Kishan scripts history | Cricket News

    Supreme Court Grants Bail to Indian Mujahideen Operatives After 12 Years in Custody | India News

    Supreme Court Grants Bail to Indian Mujahideen Operatives After 12 Years in Custody | India News