Supreme Court rebukes courts for naming rape survivors | India News


Supreme Court rebukes courts for naming rape survivors

NEW DELHI: Supreme Court has rebuked trial and high courts for disclosing the identity of rape survivors in their orders and directed them to ensure that names of survivors and family members are not mentioned in court records.A bench of Justices Sanjay Karol and N K Singh expressed concern that despite statutory safeguards and repeated directions from SC, such lapses persist. The court made the observation while convicting a rape accused, noting that the name of the minor survivor was mentioned in lower court orders.“The legislature had as far back as 1983 introduced a provision into IPC seeking to protect the identity of the victim of the offence under Section 376 IPC. The amendment was made apparently to address a specific mischief that emerged starkly from the way sexual offence cases were handled: the public disclosure of a survivor’s identity.”Strictly follow rule on not naming survivor: SCSC said : “Clearly, the intent of this Section has been given a miss in these proceedings. The name of the survivor is treated like that of any other witness and is freely used throughout the record. This must be deprecated in the strongest terms. In fact, this court has noticed earlier also that the mandate of this provision is not being followed”.The court said that a copy of this judgment be sent to all high courts to ensure strict compliance with the apex court’s order.“This has been the long-standing position in law but it has not been followed. The primary reason there amongst, one supposes, is the general indifference of the courts below and possibly even the lack of awareness of the deep stigma that follows such offences,” the Supreme Court said.Supreme Court, while convicting the accused and setting aside the acquittal order of Uttarakhand high court, said courts must not give undue importance to minor discrepancies.“A truthful witness may make honest mistakes or omit immaterial details, and such normal variation should not result in wholesale rejection of evidence. However, when omissions or contradictions relate to material facts that form the foundation of the prosecution’s version, they assume significance and may create reasonable doubt….We may observe that the approach adopted by the high court is one of attempting to pick holes in a case that otherwise has withstood the test of cross-examination. The prosecutrix has positively identified the respondentaccused and has unequivocally stated that it was he who forced himself upon her,” it said.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Watch: Clash erupts at Pappu Yadav’s press meet; man carrying knife detained | India News

    A scuffle broke out during Pappu Yadav’s press conference after a man questioned him over the Ram Temple skit controversy. NEW DELHI: A scuffle broke out during Independent MP Pappu…

    Can BJP crack Punjab? Inside its strategy to challenge AAP and Congress in 2027 | India News

    NEW DELHI: When it comes to BJP’s election playbook, there is always a method to the madness. Punjab, which votes early next year, appears to be following the same script.Sample…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Watch: Clash erupts at Pappu Yadav’s press meet; man carrying knife detained | India News

    Watch: Clash erupts at Pappu Yadav’s press meet; man carrying knife detained | India News

    ‘To end discrimination against women’: Taslima Nasreen calls for UCC implementation in India, Bangladesh and Pakisatn | India News

    ‘To end discrimination against women’: Taslima Nasreen calls for UCC implementation in India, Bangladesh and Pakisatn | India News

    ‘A disaster with no alternative’: Sunil Chhetri breaks silence on Jamshedpur FC’s shocking ISL exit | Football News

    ‘A disaster with no alternative’: Sunil Chhetri breaks silence on Jamshedpur FC’s shocking ISL exit | Football News

    25 sixes, 15 fours: Abhishek Sharma smashes 233 off 91 balls in Punjab tournment – Watch | Commonwealth Games News

    25 sixes, 15 fours: Abhishek Sharma smashes 233 off 91 balls in Punjab tournment – Watch | Commonwealth Games News

    Can BJP crack Punjab? Inside its strategy to challenge AAP and Congress in 2027 | India News

    Can BJP crack Punjab? Inside its strategy to challenge AAP and Congress in 2027 | India News

    Evening news wrap: Indonesia ferry fire kills 5, rescue teams recover Nirmal Purja’s body & more | India News

    Evening news wrap: Indonesia ferry fire kills 5, rescue teams recover Nirmal Purja’s body & more | India News