‘Who is the biggest litigant? Cost should be imposed’: SC imposes Rs 25,000 penalty on Centre over CISF dismissal case | India News


'Who is the biggest litigant? Cost should be imposed': SC imposes Rs 25,000 penalty on Centre over CISF dismissal case

The Supreme Court on Wednesday imposed costs of Rs 25,000 on the Centre for challenging a Punjab and Haryana High Court order that had set aside the dismissal of a CISF official, observing that the matter involved unnecessary litigation.Upholding the high court’s ruling, a bench of Justices B V Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan also directed that the official be granted back wages, holding that the punishment imposed was disproportionate.“We fail to understand why the Union of India has challenged the order of the high court division bench. We hear pendency, pendency. Who is the biggest litigant? Cost should be imposed,” said Justice Nagarathna, as cited by PTI.“Why can’t there be an opinion that if the high court found it disproportionate and granted relief setting aside all the orders, we shall not go to the Supreme Court? He took medical leave but he also had to deal with an elopement in his family,” she added. Referring to her recent remarks at a conference organised by the Supreme Court Bar Association, Justice Nagarathna said the court had taken the observations regarding the government’s role in the backlog of cases very seriously.“It was not just to go to some resort and come back. We made preparations, we did homework. We spoke. Not to forget,” she said.Two charges were levelled against the CISF official, absence from duty for 11 days and alleged indiscipline for purportedly conniving with a woman, the daughter of a CISF constable, to leave Mumbai and attend her wedding with his younger brother.The high court, however, noted that the 11-day absence had been explained, as the official was on sanctioned medical leave during that period.Justice Nagarathna noted that during the disciplinary proceedings, the woman involved had appeared and stated that she had no grievance against the respondent-petitioner regarding the allegation that she had run away with his brother.“It is otherwise not in dispute that the brother of the respondent-petitioner had married the lady concerned. It has, therefore, been found that in-fact there was no misconduct on the part of the respondent for which he could be removed from service,” said the High Court.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Evening News Wrap: Air India crash probe finds no fuel switch fault; RS clears Vande Mataram Bill & more | India News

    The government says no fault has been found in the Air India Boeing 787 fuel control switch, while the crash investigation continues.Parliament has cleared a Bill extending legal protection to…

    Times Samman Dehradun 2026: A tribute to brave hearts from Sainya Bhoomi | India News

    Uttarakhand has emerged as a preferred destination for defence personnel, with institutions like IMA, RIMC, etc., and a growing creative ecosystem. What gives Uttarakhand a special status is its glory…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Evening News Wrap: Air India crash probe finds no fuel switch fault; RS clears Vande Mataram Bill & more | India News

    Evening News Wrap: Air India crash probe finds no fuel switch fault; RS clears Vande Mataram Bill & more | India News

    Why Australia coach is dreaming of Ben Stokes’ ‘fairytale’ return for one last Ashes | Cricket News

    Why Australia coach is dreaming of Ben Stokes’ ‘fairytale’ return for one last Ashes | Cricket News

    RCB become first IPL franchise to cross $300 million in brand value | Cricket News

    RCB become first IPL franchise to cross $300 million in brand value | Cricket News

    Vande Mataram Bill 2026: New Legislation Enhances Protection for India’s National Song | India News

    Vande Mataram Bill 2026: New Legislation Enhances Protection for India’s National Song | India News

    Times Samman Dehradun 2026: A tribute to brave hearts from Sainya Bhoomi | India News

    Times Samman Dehradun 2026: A tribute to brave hearts from Sainya Bhoomi | India News

    Shubman Gill dethrones Daryl Mitchell! India captain reclaims ICC ODI No. 1 ranking after six months | Cricket News

    Shubman Gill dethrones Daryl Mitchell! India captain reclaims ICC ODI No. 1 ranking after six months | Cricket News