SC verdict clearing EC on SIR is full of contradictions: Congress | India News


SC verdict clearing EC on SIR is full of contradictions: Congress

NEW DELHI: Congress on Wednesday slammed the SC judgment on SIR for not mentioning a clutch of “major flaws and contradictions” in EC’s process that, it said, has “deprived crores of citizens” of voting rights. It said the judicial challenge by political parties and civil society pertained to flaws on part of the EC’s conduct and not about the legal validity of the SIR of electoral rolls.Congress spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi told a press conference that SIR has raised serious questions about the credibility of elections, as up to 80% of challenges to voters’ exclusion in West Bengal have been found to be successful till now. He said if this success rate holds, then millions of voters may have been deprived of their voting rights in the recent polls.Singhvi said the judgment is riddled with contradictions, as it did not mention glaring errors and flaws in the SIR process noticed over the past few months in different states. He said SC had ruled Aadhaar was not a proof of citizenship and EC could not adjudicate on it, but lakhs were excluded from rolls on the issue of citizenship based on 7-8 documents that SIR demanded, like ration card and parents date of birth. Similarly, he said EC had imposed an excessively short deadline for SIR for crores of persons, which led to massive exclusions, while elections were held before they could be adjudicated upon. “It is an issue the court should have pondered over.” TMC MP Kalyan Banerjee said the judgment was confined to the Bihar case and could not be treated as an all-India ruling, asserting issues raised in Bengal were “completely different”.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    ‘How is unelected minister continuing for over six months?’ SC raps Bihar govt | India News

    NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Thursday questioned the Bihar government over the continuation of Panchayati Raj minister Deepak Prakash, asking the state to explain how he remained in office…

    Why Bankipur bypoll grabbed national attention and what it means for Prashant Kishor | India News

    PK is making a second attempt to establish himself as an electoral force by staking his claim in the Bankipur bypoll NEW DELHI: Will Bihar’s Bankipur stand with the BJP,…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    ‘A date for history books’: India to face Brazil in historic football match in Kolkata | Football News

    ‘A date for history books’: India to face Brazil in historic football match in Kolkata | Football News

    Future India captain? Selector explains why 15-year-old Vaibhav Sooryavanshi was named East Zone vice-captain | Cricket News

    Future India captain? Selector explains why 15-year-old Vaibhav Sooryavanshi was named East Zone vice-captain | Cricket News

    ‘How is unelected minister continuing for over six months?’ SC raps Bihar govt | India News

    ‘How is unelected minister continuing for over six months?’ SC raps Bihar govt | India News

    ‘Can pellet guns be used against peaceful protesters under any circumstances?’ CJP slams SC | India News

    ‘Can pellet guns be used against peaceful protesters under any circumstances?’ CJP slams SC | India News

    ‘Incredibly disappointed’: Commonwealth Games wheelchair medallists forced to race again after shock first-lap crash | Commonwealth Games News

    ‘Incredibly disappointed’: Commonwealth Games wheelchair medallists forced to race again after shock first-lap crash | Commonwealth Games News

    ‘Few boxes to tick’: Josh Hazlewood eyes BGT win in India, Ashes in England before retirement | Cricket News

    ‘Few boxes to tick’: Josh Hazlewood eyes BGT win in India, Ashes in England before retirement | Cricket News